S5.A
Distinguish a property defect from psychological stigma
In Milliken v. Jacono, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that purely psychological stigma from a murder or suicide is not a material property defect that the seller must disclose. A buyer may care deeply about that history, but the court did not turn that reaction into a property defect.
Keep the holding narrow. Physical damage, contamination or a dangerous condition is a different issue and must be evaluated under the usual rules. The decision does not authorize a licensee to lie in response to a question. A licensee's duties of honesty and good faith still apply.
Work the example
A house has a past murder-suicide but no associated physical damage or unsafe condition in the facts given.
Is the psychological stigma itself a material defect requiring seller disclosure in Pennsylvania?
Show answer and reasoning
No. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court distinguished purely psychological stigma from a material property defect.
Do not generalize that holding into permission to conceal physical conditions or make false statements.
Stigma is not a substitute for the statutory defect test.
Sources and full lesson context
- Pennsylvania authorityPA Supreme Court, Milliken v. Jacono (2014)
- Pennsylvania authority49 Pa. Code § 35.292, Duties to all consumers
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.
S5.A
Ask about water history and who maintains the drainage
Elena's basement water problem matters even if the house is outside a mapped high-risk flood area. The current form asks about water leakage and accumulation, flood plains, drainage and related land conditions. A map does not cancel the duty to disclose what the seller knows about the property.
Storm water facilities can include a constructed swale, basin, drain, culvert or pipe. Since 2015, section 7304(b)(17) has required disclosure of their location, condition if known, and whether continuing maintenance belongs to the owner or someone else. This requirement applies now. It doesn't depend on Act 74.
A useful reading of the statement connects the answers: previous water entry, attempted repairs, drainage structures and maintenance responsibility. Ask for available supporting information and refer technical questions to the appropriate expert. A sump pump, or an assurance that 'it only happens in heavy rain,' doesn't answer the disclosure question.
Work the example
The seller knows that an owner-maintained drainage swale runs across the lot. The older form being used has no separate storm water heading.
May the seller leave that information out because the heading is missing?
Show answer and reasoning
No. Supply the required location, known condition and maintenance-responsibility information.
The statute supplies requirements that an older form may not display in a separate field.
An old form does not erase a later statutory disclosure requirement.
Sources and full lesson context
- Pennsylvania authority49 Pa. Code § 35.335a, minimum seller disclosure form
- Pennsylvania authority68 Pa.C.S. § 7304(b)(17), storm water disclosure added in 2015
- Pennsylvania authority68 Pa.C.S. chapter 73, seller disclosure duties and remedies
- Pennsylvania authority68 Pa.C.S. § 7102, material defect and storm water definitions
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.