S5.A
Start with the property and the kind of transfer
Elena is selling a three-bedroom house in Reading. She remembers water coming through a basement wall after heavy rain. Before thinking about the asking price, she needs to work out what the buyer must be told. The seller disclosure statement is where she reports what she knows about the property. It's a different document from the Consumer Notice, which explains business relationships.
Pennsylvania's Residential Real Estate Transfers Law generally covers transfers of interests in property with one to four residential dwelling units. A sale is only one route: exchanges, installment sales, leases with an option to purchase, and transfers of residential condominium or cooperative units can also qualify. A plain lease with no purchase option isn't a covered transfer.
First check section 7103 for the scope and transfer exceptions. Then check section 7302 for the additional seller-disclosure exceptions. A seller who has no agent is still a seller. Listing a property 'for sale by owner' does not remove the duty. A five-unit building falls outside this particular one-to-four-unit framework, but that does not authorize concealment or erase duties under other law.
Work the example
An owner offers a duplex through a lease with an option to purchase. No statutory exception applies.
Does calling the arrangement a lease remove it from the disclosure law?
Show answer and reasoning
No. A lease with an option to purchase is one of the covered transfer methods.
The facts about the property and agreement matter more than the label used in an advertisement.
Check unit count, transaction type and exceptions before deciding which disclosure is required.
Sources and full lesson context
- Pennsylvania authority68 Pa.C.S. § 7103, residential transfer exceptions
- Pennsylvania authority68 Pa.C.S. § 7302, seller disclosure exceptions
- Pennsylvania authority68 Pa.C.S. chapter 73, seller disclosure duties and remedies
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.
S5.A
What makes a defect material
A material defect is a property problem serious enough to substantially harm its value or create an unreasonable risk to people there. Either route can qualify. An unsafe electrical condition need not wait for a failed sale to become material.
Age alone is different. A furnace near the end of its expected life can still be working fine. A furnace the seller knows has a cracked heat exchanger is a different fact pattern. Similarly, a buyer's dislike of old cabinets is not the same as known structural damage.
Section 7303 requires disclosure of known material defects. Do not turn the form's reference to defects that are not readily observable into advice to hide an obvious problem or answer a form question falsely. Read each question, disclose the facts it asks for, and distinguish a visible symptom from a hidden cause.
Work the example
Elena has an older furnace that works normally and a basement wall that leaks after storms.
Does the age of the furnace make both conditions material defects?
Show answer and reasoning
No. Age isn't enough. The known water problem needs disclosure and evaluation on its facts.
The test concerns the problem and its effect on value or safety, not a birthday on an appliance label.
Material defect: a problem that significantly hurts value or creates an unreasonable risk. Age alone doesn't qualify.
Sources and full lesson context
- Pennsylvania authority68 Pa.C.S. § 7102, material defect and storm water definitions
- Pennsylvania authority68 Pa.C.S. chapter 73, seller disclosure duties and remedies
- Pennsylvania authority49 Pa. Code § 35.335a, minimum seller disclosure form
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.