S5.C
Do not import the federal four-unit rule into Pennsylvania
Start with the PHRA’s definitions. Sections 4(i) and 4(k) exclude a qualifying personal residence offered for rent from the definition of housing accommodation. The residence must contain living quarters for no more than two independently living individuals, groups or families, and the owner or lessee must use it as a genuine home. A qualifying owner-occupied duplex can fall within this exclusion; a building with three or more separate households doesn’t qualify just because its owner lives there. This rental exclusion is different from the federal four-unit rule.
Section 5(h)(10) covers rooms in a landlord-occupied rooming house with a common entrance, specified single-sex shared housing, and certain religious, denominational, charitable, educational, private and fraternal organizations. Read its wording together with federal and local law. Qualified older-person housing has its own age and familial-status provision discussed earlier.
The Civil Rights Act of 1866, now reflected in 42 U.S.C. section 1982, protects equal property rights against racial discrimination. A Fair Housing Act small-owner exemption does not create permission to discriminate based on race. Each law has its own exemptions, and owner occupancy is not an escape hatch.
Work the example
An owner lives in one apartment of a Pennsylvania four-unit building. Each apartment is separate. The owner assumes the federal small-building provision also exempts the rental from the PHRA.
What is the mistake?
Show answer and reasoning
Pennsylvania’s personal-residence exclusion stops at two households.
Four separate apartments exceed the personal-residence definition, and the owner living there doesn’t make the building a qualifying rooming house.
PA rental exclusion: owner-occupied, two households at most. Federal: up to four units.
Sources and full lesson context
- Pennsylvania authorityPennsylvania Human Relations Act, definitions, housing duties and enforcement
- Federal source42 U.S.C. § 3603, limited owner exemptions
- Federal source42 U.S.C. § 1982, equal property rights
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.
S5.C + N5.C
A reasonable accommodation changes a rule or service
Under the federal housing definition, disability includes a physical or mental impairment substantially limiting a major life activity, a record of such impairment, or being regarded as having it. The definition excludes current illegal use of or addiction to controlled substances. Do not assume a history of treatment or recovery is the same as current illegal use.
A reasonable accommodation is a change or exception in a rule, policy, practice or service that may be necessary for a person with a disability to have an equal opportunity to use and enjoy housing. Equal treatment can require an exception, not rigid enforcement of an identical rule.
Consider a tenant with limited mobility who needs a reserved parking space near the entrance despite a first-come parking policy. Ask whether the requested change is disability-related, necessary and reasonable. Handle the request promptly and consider effective alternatives if a particular request cannot reasonably be granted.
Do not demand an entire medical history simply because someone requests an accommodation. When the disability or related need is not apparent, the relevant issue is reliable information needed to evaluate that request, not a diagnosis collected for routine screening. A direct-threat decision needs an individualized factual assessment, not a stereotype about a disability.
Work the example
A tenant with a mobility disability requests a practical reserved parking space near the entrance. The manager refuses solely because the first-come policy applies to everyone.
Why is that answer insufficient?
Show answer and reasoning
A reasonable exception may be necessary to give the tenant equal use of the housing.
The accommodation duty asks whether the policy needs to change in these circumstances. Applying the rule to everyone doesn’t answer that.
Accommodation: change the rule so the person can use the housing.
Sources and full lesson context
- Pennsylvania authorityPennsylvania Human Relations Act, definitions, housing duties and enforcement
- Federal source42 U.S.C. § 3604, housing discrimination and disability duties
- Federal source24 CFR § 100.204, reasonable accommodations
- Federal source42 U.S.C. § 3602, definitions
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.