N3.C
Select and verify genuinely comparable sales
The subject is the property being valued; comparables are other properties used as evidence. Compare the rights conveyed, location, use, size, condition, quality, features and transaction circumstances. A nearby sale can be a poor comparable if it serves a different market.
Closed sales show completed transactions. Listings and pending contracts can provide useful context but do not establish verified closing prices. Verify sale terms, unusual concessions, relationships and relevant dates before relying on a reported amount.
Comparable selection seeks evidence that competes with the subject and supports reliable adjustments. A small adjustment is not proof of a good comparable if key differences were ignored. Price per square foot is a useful comparison unit, but extra square footage usually adds less per foot than the average.
Work the example
A house across the street is twice the subject’s size and recently rebuilt. A slightly more distant sale competes directly with the subject and has verified terms.
Must the closest house receive the most weight?
Show answer and reasoning
No. Similarity and reliable evidence matter more than distance.
The nearer house differs in size and condition. The farther sale competes directly with the subject.
Verify the sale and the competitive market before adjusting its price.
Sources and full lesson context
- Loan-program guidanceFannie Mae, comparable selection and verification (program guidance)Fannie Mae requirements for loans covered by its guide.
- Loan-program guidanceFannie Mae, comparable adjustments and market evidence (program guidance)Fannie Mae requirements for loans covered by its guide.
- National concept referenceCalifornia DRE, Appraisal and Valuation: economic conceptsAnother state's teaching guide, used for general concepts. Its state-specific rules do not establish Pennsylvania law.
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.
N3.C
Adjust the comparable toward the subject
In a sales comparison grid, adjustments are made to the comparable’s sale price to reflect differences from the subject. If the comparable is superior, subtract the supported value difference. If it is inferior, add the supported difference. Do not add an improvement twice by also adjusting the subject.
Use market-supported amounts. Matched-pair evidence compares sales that are similar except for a feature, with other differences accounted for. The feature’s installation cost rarely equals its contribution. An adjustment given in an exam question is an assumption for that problem, not a market rate to memorize.
Consider transaction and market conditions as well as physical differences. An older comparable may need an upward time adjustment in a rising market or a downward one in a falling market. Concession adjustments reflect the supported effect on price, not necessarily the seller’s full expenditure. Avoid double-counting an influence in two adjustment lines.
Change the comparable. Keep the subject fixed.
The comparable sold for $350,000. Change only its garage relative to the subject. The stated market-supported difference is $18,000 when the garages differ.
The comparable’s garage offers $18,000 more value than the subject’s garage.
Adjusted comparable: $332,000
$350,000 − $18,000 = $332,000
Subtract the comparable’s advantage to estimate what its price would indicate with the subject’s garage.
This exercise isolates one supported difference. Real comparisons may require other adjustments and reconciliation; the result is not an appraisal.
Work the example
A comparable sold for $310,000. Its extra garage contributes $18,000 more than the subject’s garage. The comparable lacks a patio that contributes $7,000 to the subject. No other adjustments apply.
What is the adjusted sale price?
Show answer and reasoning
$299,000.
$310,000 − $18,000 + $7,000 = $299,000. Subtract the superior garage and add the missing patio.
Superior comparable: subtract. Inferior comparable: add. Use supported differences.
Sources and full lesson context
- Loan-program guidanceFannie Mae, comparable adjustments and market evidence (program guidance)Fannie Mae requirements for loans covered by its guide.
- National concept referenceCalifornia DRE, Appraisal and Valuation: economic conceptsAnother state's teaching guide, used for general concepts. Its state-specific rules do not establish Pennsylvania law.
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.