N5.B
Who earns the fee under an open listing
An open listing is nonexclusive. The owner can list with several brokers and can also sell without any of them. Only the broker who produces the buyer earns the fee; holding a listing isn’t enough.
Procuring cause asks whose efforts actually brought about the sale. Being first to mention the property or last to write the offer doesn’t decide it. The agreement, the continuity of each broker’s efforts and any intervening events all matter.
Cooperation can be useful, but another broker’s fee arrangement does not silently become yours. Confirm authority and compensation terms before relying on them.
Work the example
An owner gives open listings to three brokers. Broker B alone produces the completed qualifying sale.
Who earns the fee?
Show answer and reasoning
Broker B, subject to the agreement and the law.
Brokers A and C don’t earn a fee just because they also held open listings.
Open listing: only the broker who produces the buyer is paid. The owner can sell fee-free.
Sources and full lesson context
- National concept referenceCalifornia DRE, agency and fiduciary concepts: state referenceAnother state's teaching guide, used for general concepts. Its state-specific rules do not establish Pennsylvania law.
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.
N5.B
Spot the conflict in a net listing
A net listing sets an amount the owner is to receive and treats the excess as the broker’s compensation. That structure can encourage an agent to focus on personal gain rather than the owner’s best interests. A hidden resale opportunity or understated market value makes the conflict worse.
Some states prohibit or restrict net listings. No single national law makes them valid or illegal everywhere. Know the definition and the conflict, then apply the state rule. A seller’s net-proceeds estimate isn’t a net listing.
For example, ignoring other costs, a $330,000 sale against a promised $300,000 net would leave $30,000 for the broker. The math shows the incentive; it doesn’t make the arrangement lawful or reasonable.
Work the example
The broker proposes keeping everything above the seller’s guaranteed net instead of negotiating a stated service fee.
What kind of arrangement is this?
Show answer and reasoning
A net listing.
The excess sets the broker’s pay, which creates a direct conflict. Check state law.
Net listing: the broker keeps everything above the seller’s net. Many states ban or restrict it.
Sources and full lesson context
- National concept referenceCalifornia DRE, agency and fiduciary concepts: state referenceAnother state's teaching guide, used for general concepts. Its state-specific rules do not establish Pennsylvania law.
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.