N1.A
Emblements: who harvests the crop
Emblements, called fructus industriales in many exam materials, are crops produced by annual cultivation, such as corn or wheat. Contrast them with natural growth and perennial plantings, called fructus naturales, which are part of the land. Trees and orchards aren’t tenant crops a farmer can carry off.
The traditional doctrine protects a tenant whose tenancy of uncertain length ends unexpectedly through no fault of his own. The tenant may come back to harvest crops planted before the tenancy ended. The tenant may not plant another season’s crop or keep occupying the farm.
Read why and when the tenancy ends. A fixed end date, a voluntary departure and an unexpected termination lead to different answers: a tenant who knew the lease’s end date generally has no emblements claim. State statutes and the lease can also govern crop rights. The linked New York decision illustrates the doctrine; its facts aren’t a rule for all fifty states.
Work the example
A tenant planted annual corn before an uncertain tenancy ended unexpectedly, through no fault of the tenant.
What does the traditional emblements rule protect?
Show answer and reasoning
Entry to harvest that crop, not a new season of planting.
The protection covers the crop cultivated during the tenancy. It doesn’t extend the lease.
Emblements: annual crops a tenant planted, harvested after an unexpected end.
Sources and full lesson context
- Other-state exampleNew York courts, Van Amburgh v. Boadle: emblements example (2024)Used to explain a concept or compare state rules. Apply the jurisdiction named in the question.
- National concept referenceCalifornia DRE, Property: general terminology and fixture principles (state reference)Another state's teaching guide, used for general concepts. Its state-specific rules do not establish Pennsylvania law.
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.
N1.A
Follow an item as its classification changes
Attachment, also called annexation, can turn personal property into a fixture. Installing a new furnace as a permanent building system is a common example. Severance runs the other way: a tree cut into logs is no longer part of the land.
Changing what an item is doesn’t give anyone permission to change it. A seller who rips out a fixture already promised to the buyer may breach the agreement, even though the detached object is now movable. Ask two questions: what is the item now, and who had the right to detach or transfer it?
A bill of sale transfers personal property. It doesn’t replace a deed for the land. When a deal includes both, list the personal items in the agreement instead of assuming everything on the premises goes with the house.
Work the example
With proper authority, an owner cuts a standing tree into firewood and sells the logs.
What change has occurred?
Show answer and reasoning
Severance, followed by a transfer of personal property.
The tree was part of the land; the cut logs are movable goods.
Attachment: chattel becomes real property. Severance: the reverse.
Sources and full lesson context
- National concept referenceCalifornia DRE, Property: general terminology and fixture principles (state reference)Another state's teaching guide, used for general concepts. Its state-specific rules do not establish Pennsylvania law.
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.