N2.B
Actual, constructive and inquiry notice
Actual notice is what a person really knows. A buyer who has been told about an earlier sale can’t ignore it just because the deed isn’t recorded. Constructive notice is knowledge the law charges you with, mainly through documents properly recorded in the chain of title.
Possession and other visible facts can put a buyer on inquiry notice. If someone other than the seller lives in the house, ask whether that person has a lease, an ownership claim or another right. Being a buyer without notice takes more than not having personally read a deed.
Recording mistakes, bad indexing, the wrong county or a document outside the chain can keep constructive notice from arising. Not every paper in a public office gives notice of every claim. On the exam, use the facts and the recording rule given; the forms of notice can have different consequences.
Work the example
Before buying, a buyer reads an unrecorded deed showing an earlier transfer to someone else.
Does the buyer have actual notice of that transfer?
Show answer and reasoning
Yes.
The buyer knows about the earlier deed, even though it isn’t recorded yet.
Actual notice: you know. Constructive: it’s recorded. Inquiry: the facts should make you ask.
Sources and full lesson context
- National concept referenceCalifornia DRE, Title to Real Property: ownership, liens and restrictions (state reference)Another state's teaching guide, used for general concepts. Its state-specific rules do not establish Pennsylvania law.
- Pennsylvania authorityPennsylvania Recording of Deeds Act, § 1 as amended: notice and priority
- Other-state exampleFlorida § 695.01, protection of purchasers without notice (state example)Used to explain a concept or compare state rules. Apply the jurisdiction named in the question.
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.
N2.B
Race, notice and race-notice statutes
Recording puts an instrument in the public land records, in the county where the land sits, and protects the holder against later competing claims. Recording isn’t title insurance, doesn’t cure a forged deed and doesn’t mean the recorder has decided who owns the land.
There are three recording-act models. Under a race statute, whoever records first wins, notice or not. Under a notice statute, a later buyer for value who takes without notice of the earlier deed wins, even if the earlier buyer records first afterward. Under a race-notice statute, the later buyer must both take without notice and record first.
Pennsylvania is generally treated as a race-notice state. Under its recording statute (21 P.S. § 351), an unrecorded deed is void against a later good-faith purchaser for value without notice who records first. So in Pennsylvania, a later buyer who knew about the earlier deed loses even if she records first, and a later buyer without notice still has to win the race to the recorder of deeds.
Change the recording rule. Compare the result.
O conveys to A first. Before A records, O conveys the same interest to B. Both are buyers for value, and the instruments otherwise qualify for the stated model.
Buyer B has priority in this model
B bought for value without disqualifying notice. The supplied notice model does not add a requirement that B also record first.
This is a defined exam model. Actual statutes have eligibility rules and exceptions; it does not decide a real title dispute or excuse a fraudulent conveyance.
Work the example
O conveys to A, who doesn’t record. B later buys the same land for value without notice. A then records before B. Apply a pure notice statute.
Who has priority?
Show answer and reasoning
B.
B qualified as a purchaser without notice at the time of purchase. Under a race-notice statute like Pennsylvania’s, A would win because A recorded first.
Pennsylvania is race-notice: the later buyer must lack notice and record first.
Sources and full lesson context
- Other-state exampleNorth Carolina G.S. 47-18, recording priority (state example)Used to explain a concept or compare state rules. Apply the jurisdiction named in the question.
- Other-state exampleFlorida § 695.01, protection of purchasers without notice (state example)Used to explain a concept or compare state rules. Apply the jurisdiction named in the question.
- Pennsylvania authorityPennsylvania Recording of Deeds Act, § 1 as amended: notice and priority
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.