N4.D
When an acceptance takes effect
The offeror makes the proposal and the offeree receives it. A listing or ad is an invitation for offers, not a promise to sell to the first person who offers the asking price. The owner decides whether to accept.
An acceptance must match the offer’s terms and follow its required method and timing. Silence isn’t acceptance of a purchase offer. A signed response left in a drawer may fail a communication or receipt requirement.
Not every acceptance takes effect only on receipt. Under the common-law mailbox rule, a properly sent acceptance can be effective when dispatched. But an offer can require receipt, state rules vary and options have their own treatment. Real estate questions often supply a delivery clause; apply it, and don’t stretch the mailbox rule to email or e-signature platforms.
Work the example
The offer requires the buyer to receive the seller’s signed acceptance by noon. The seller signs at 11:50 a.m.; it arrives at 12:10 p.m. No extension applies.
Was this a timely acceptance under that provision?
Show answer and reasoning
No.
Signing was not enough because the offer required receipt by noon. A late response may become a new proposal.
Acceptance must follow the offer’s terms, method and deadline. Silence isn’t acceptance.
Sources and full lesson context
- National concept referenceCalifornia DRE, contract concepts and transfer: state reference, general principles onlyAnother state's teaching guide, used for general concepts. Its state-specific rules do not establish Pennsylvania law.
- National concept referenceCornell LII, mailbox rule and limits: general legal referenceBackground explanation. State law and the terms of the document can change the outcome.
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.
N4.D
Track which offer is still available
A counteroffer rejects the original offer and proposes different terms. Changing the price or closing date and sending that back is not an acceptance. A question about flexibility isn’t necessarily a counteroffer.
An offer can usually be withdrawn before acceptance takes effect, as long as the withdrawal is communicated. An enforceable option is the big exception: the owner can’t revoke the offer during the option period.
Offers also end through rejection, lapse and other events recognized by law. A rejected offer doesn’t come back when the counteroffer is rejected; someone has to make it again. Once a purchase contract forms, walking away is a breach question, not revocation of an offer.
Try a different fact pattern
Follow the contract decision
Six short scenarios. Pick a response, check the reasoning, then change the situation. These exercises are for learning; the linked practice saves your study history.
An offer requires signed acceptance received by the buyer by 5 p.m. The seller signs at 4:50 p.m.; the buyer receives it at 5:10 p.m. No extension applies.
Work the example
A buyer offers $300,000. The seller communicates a $310,000 counteroffer. The buyer rejects it and later says, “I accept my original $300,000 offer.”
Is there a contract on those facts alone?
Show answer and reasoning
No.
The original offer was rejected by the counteroffer and has not been renewed or accepted by the seller.
A counteroffer kills the original offer. Rejecting the counteroffer doesn’t revive it.
Sources and full lesson context
- National concept referenceCalifornia DRE, contract concepts and transfer: state reference, general principles onlyAnother state's teaching guide, used for general concepts. Its state-specific rules do not establish Pennsylvania law.
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.